The Best of Both Worlds

What if we could use Binet's formula without needing this extra precision early on?

When you compute values involving square roots by hand, I imagine you probably wait until the end and only then pull out a calculator if you need the answer in decimal. For example, if you're computing (1+2)(3+2)(1 + \sqrt{2})(3 + \sqrt{2}), you might first just work the exact answer by expanding the product, getting 5+425 + 4 \sqrt{2}, and then computing this to whatever precision you need.

We can steal this approach. In the same way that complex numbers result by adding a new element i=1i = \sqrt{-1} and all of the new numbers you can make by adding and multiplying it with the existing ones, we can imagine setting j=5j = \sqrt{5} and representing numbers as a+bja + bj.

Let's write out the rules of adding and multiplying in this new number system:

(a+b5)+(c+d5)=(a+c)+(b+d)5(a+b5)×(c+d5)=ac+ad5+bc5+bd55=(ac+5bd)+(ad+bc)5 \gdef\zv#1#2{#1 + #2 \sqrt{5}} \begin{aligned} \left(\zv{a}{b}\right) + \left(\zv{c}{d}\right) &= \zv{\left(a + c\right)}{\left(b + d\right)} \\ \left(\zv{a}{b}\right) \times \left(\zv{c}{d}\right) &= ac + ad \sqrt{5} + bc \sqrt{5} + bd \sqrt{5} \sqrt{5} \\ &= \zv{(ac + 5bd)}{(ad + bc)} \\ \end{aligned}

The Best of Both Worlds

What if we could use Binet's formula without needing this extra precision early on?

When you compute values involving square roots by hand, I imagine you probably wait until the end and only then pull out a calculator if you need the answer in decimal. For example, if you're computing (1+2)(3+2)(1 + \sqrt{2})(3 + \sqrt{2}), you might first just work the exact answer by expanding the product, getting 5+425 + 4 \sqrt{2}, and then computing this to whatever precision you need.

We can steal this approach. In the same way that complex numbers result by adding a new element i=1i = \sqrt{-1} and all of the new numbers you can make by adding and multiplying it with the existing ones, we can imagine setting j=5j = \sqrt{5} and representing numbers as a+bja + bj.

Let's write out the rules of adding and multiplying in this new number system:

(a+b5)+(c+d5)=(a+c)+(b+d)5(a+b5)×(c+d5)=ac+ad5+bc5+bd55=(ac+5bd)+(ad+bc)5 \gdef\zv#1#2{#1 + #2 \sqrt{5}} \begin{aligned} \left(\zv{a}{b}\right) + \left(\zv{c}{d}\right) &= \zv{\left(a + c\right)}{\left(b + d\right)} \\ \left(\zv{a}{b}\right) \times \left(\zv{c}{d}\right) &= ac + ad \sqrt{5} + bc \sqrt{5} + bd \sqrt{5} \sqrt{5} \\ &= \zv{(ac + 5bd)}{(ad + bc)} \\ \end{aligned}